Thanks for the report! I so agree, when you have the best beach on the island right out your slider, why would you want to leave??

I do think we will try Palapa Grill when we are next in Simpson Bay. Sounds great! I think with regard to Frenchy Ludo's the conclusion is that the smell is based on the prevailing wind. Wind out of the right direction, no problem. Wind out of the wrong direction, yikes!!