Was good for us. Guests ordered the grouper fingers and was disappointed. Under cooked and mushy. They are usually great too.

That is surprising. Normally they are good.

I know. Must have been an off night.

Did they send them back? Can’t fix if they don’t know.

Yes. Cook said that's the way it is supposed to be but offered something else instead. I and my wife tried a bite and we both confirmed it was mushy too. Other couple didn't want to wait for something else so just ate the fries.

Well that stinks!! We had them last week and all four of us raved about them to the point we wanted to try to slip in another day for more!!!

Probably going to be fine next time. All depends on the cook who prepares them.

OUR FAVORITE SNACK FOR HAPPY HOUR... LOVE LOVE LOVE THEM

Had great Bloody Mary's there yesterday morning. Might have to go again today.

They had a special this week - seafood soup - with a kick! It was amazing!

We had good friends that just stayed there that thought it was way overpriced for the money and not really that nice. Very out of the way if you want to do anything so they will go back to staying in the Simpson Bay area where most of the tourist activities are. Seems nothing at that location has ever been much of a hit or failed.

forever--sorry?? Stayed where? This thread is talking about food at the Yacht Club.

I'm confused by your post. What and where are you talking about.