Returning to SXM following Irma

We always stayed at Club O while visiting St Martin in the past but have not been back to the island since 2017 because Club O is no longer. We are looking at Jaredin d' O and Adam and Eve properties. for our visit in April 2022. We would appreciate input from those of you that have stayed at either or both to help us make a decision. Comments appreciated.

Jim--I'm too lazy to search for it right now, but I know someone posted just such a comparison fairly recently. Hopefully the author of that note will respond.

We've stayed at Jardin d'O a few years ago, never at Adam & Eve, it was "okay" nothing great, lovely pool are and that's about it. you have to be very careful what room you get, most of them are small and tucked away, it wouldn't be my first choice. Have you considered Club Fantastico?