At the end of our sailing trip, we (a group of 7) will be staying one night at the Windward Passage. Looking for suggestions for a restaurant not too far away.
We routinely hit Pie Whole for wood fired pizza and a BIG beer list. Hook, Line & Sinker is solid. We're also fans of Gladys' Cafe. Over st Yacht Haven we've enjoyed Fat Turtle.
It is a 5 minute walk to Frenchtown's restaurants from the Windward Passage Hotel.Lots of choices and price points -- all owner operated and note that most all the places there are closed on SUNDAY nights for dinner.
HL&S is nice. Sometimes slow but ALWAYS good. We almost always eat there the evening we arrive for a bareboat charter. It's also right next to CYOA, so if you want to visit and check out their boats...
Maybe 200 yards south west of them is Oceana, which is a pretty upscale restaurant. Nicer and more expensive than HL&S. Good food and open-air dining with a nice tropical breeze.
HLS is an excellent choice! Do make a reservation as it is not a huge place. Their seafood is always excellent, but if you have had your fill of mahi, conch and lobster, their duck is also very good!