Best place for lobster in Simpson bay

Tonight is our last night. And we want to make it special. Where is the best place to have lobster termidor in Simpson bay?

thanks,
alecu

Pineapple Pete. No contest!

Agree. Had it two weeks ago and it was as good as ever.

IMHO
Will agree only because Chesterfield's is not open yet.

….and Chesterfield's is not in Simpson Bay......

Pineapple Pete it is. Thanks for answering the question.

alecu

Thanks for the Geography lesson. But if it were open it would be worth the "long drive" imho.

Pineapple Pete is our go to for Lobster Thermidor. I dream about it ALL winter!

Anyone know the status of SkipJack's? My favorite place for lobster for the past several years. Greenhouse in Simpson Bay is also good and usually priced well.

Won't be open for a while. Saw Jim there working on it.

Is it walkable from SB resort?

Yes, you can walk to Pineapple Pete from Simpson Bay Resort. It's a bit of a hike back up the hill after dinner, but doable.

I would say, yes you CAN, depending on your level of fitness. I would say that you should NOT walk it after night. There are no streetlights and no sidewalks on Welfare Road.

Saturday night walking to our car from Buchaneer was dicey! No sidewalks, holes, potholes, cars.
I don’t recommend doing that at night.