If you had one night in SXM

And I’m paying the bill where would you so to dinner?

If you are paying for dinner, then I'd vote for either Le Tropicana in Marigot or L'auberge Gourmande in Grand Case.
If you are also paying for the wine, then Ocean 82 in Grand Case, because of this:

PROVIDED that Dino is still the executive chef there, LaSamanna.

8:15 reservation at La Villa

Ocean 82!

Sunset dinner at LeCigale

My vote, for one of the most romantic settings on the island, with great food, is La Cigale.

Their Grand Marnier Souffle is off the charts fantastic!

Bistrot Caraibes, hands down!

I’d vote for Bistro Caraibes too but it has been 15 years, so I’m not sure my vote counts.😊

It would be a Progressive Dinner

Moulin Rouge for Champagne & appetizers with Olivier, get in the Limo with Champagne to Bistro Caribe’s for Lobster, other entrees and walk across the street to Ocean 82 for desert and after dinner drinks. Obviously Bistro and the Brothers are the main attraction for us.

Bistrot Caraibes

Wow...hmmm...should we try all?! Our honeymoon 34 years ago...La Tastevan...closed now, but blew our minds!