TravelTalkOnline
Posted By: Pmcwethy Secret Seafood - 05/02/2025 02:15 PM
Anyone been to Secret Seafood recently? If so, how was the experience?
TIA.
Posted By: jmbcomms Re: Secret Seafood - 05/25/2025 07:32 PM
We love it. Nice location, very good food, reasonable prices. "Lasagna" waitress is outstanding, and Ziggy Chang is a hoot & a half. GO.
Posted By: RonDon Re: Secret Seafood - 05/25/2025 09:14 PM
Mixed reviews you can view by doing a "search"
Posted By: SXMScubaman Re: Secret Seafood - 05/25/2025 09:44 PM
He pretty much posts daily on your site and I've read mixed reviews on various sxm sites that don't have paying sponsors.
Posted By: ruralcarrier Re: Secret Seafood - 05/25/2025 11:29 PM
Correct, mixed reviews at best.
Posted By: CaribLee Re: Secret Seafood - 05/26/2025 12:28 AM
We went recently and had a very good experience. Food was good. Lovely setting. No complaints here.

Attached picture 20250513_190022.jpg
Posted By: Todd Re: Secret Seafood - 05/26/2025 01:40 AM
Originally Posted by SXMScubaman
He pretty much posts daily on your site and I've read mixed reviews on various sxm sites that don't have paying sponsors.

Are you saying that the positive review is because they are a paying sponsor? Does that devalue an opinion if only one would only support people that pay for their website ads? Just wondering, because that's my opinion.
Posted By: StMartinFan Re: Secret Seafood - 05/26/2025 03:25 AM
We had dinner there in March. They were very busy and one of our group got food poisoning from undercooked mahi-mahi. We also thought the service wasn't great. It was clear they were understaffed for the number of guests.
Posted By: ruralcarrier Re: Secret Seafood - 05/26/2025 10:50 AM
Imagine that.
Posted By: toothdoc Re: Secret Seafood - 05/26/2025 01:25 PM
We had a terrible experience with 1 1/2 hour wait for our food as did everyone around us. They were so confused and understaffed that there was no one to take our money at the end of the meal. We have gone there since they opened and can walk there from the Royal Palm, but would never return. Too many good places that appreciate our business.
Posted By: megamania Re: Secret Seafood - 05/28/2025 09:40 PM
We were there in January. It was a birthday dinner for me. I had the snapper and it was NOT good at all,,,,sooo disappointing. Having said that, most of what other people in our group of 11 had was okay. Ziggy is a hoot......very welcoming, and fun. Have had way better food at many other places, so am not sure if we would return....will see.
Posted By: SXMScubaman Re: Secret Seafood - 05/29/2025 12:27 AM
Ziggy the comedian can't make up for poor service and food.
© TravelTalkOnline