What strikes me as really weird about this ruling is that the evidence linking Kildare and Endless Vacation was never presented. From what I understand of St. Maarten court proceedings this was an injunction case, which is a sort of a mini hearing and limited in scope. This still leaves plenty of room for further evidence in what is referred to as a main case. It still strikes me as odd that the lawyers for the Association did not even submit this evidence for the judge to see. As said in the main post, it seems this is far from over.