Assuming like most arriving in the BVI after a long day of travel everyone will be tired and unlikely to make much use of a beach. ..and early the next day to the boat I would second Maria's by the sea for your crew. In years past we would meet up with friends at THE Dove ..or cafe de mare..depending on budget and degree of fatigue. The Dove changed hands and I hear it is not the same..was fine dining at its best..still have Cafe Demare or Pussers close by. For a little extra $$ can get the newbies a view out ver road harbor with a balcony. Always clean..good AC and hot water . The rooms facing the harbor are only a few bucks more..come with a balcony and will put your crew in an island vibe while still enjoying very good accomodations.