I agree with those who recommend the newer boat - all else being equal. However, Take a look at the cockpit on the Jeanneau - and compare it to the Bavaria. The Jeanneau is much larger. We chartered the Jeanneau 53 last year, which has a similar cockpit and it really was nice. The swim platform on the Bavaria is nice at anchor, but the large cockpit on the Jeanneau really allows plenty of room for everyone under sail and at anchor. Tough choice, but IF the Jeanneau is well maintained (I have not chartered from Horizon) I don't think you can beat that cockpit.