Personal decision certainly ...if one night certainly STT..but 5 nights, would be my last choice of options . To each their own, but since the early 90s with multiple trips a year to STJ and for last15 to the BVis I've never missed an afternoon flight from STT while staying on STJ or In the BVI on a boat or land. If concerned about ferry.end your trip on VG and leave on a Tuesday Thursday or Sat.. Have never heard of them not being near on time with the Speedy's direct to STT ferry..but we always go later to Roadtown and on to STT.