There are just so many great places in Anguilla, and to me, Scilly Cay is not one of them.
TT is a wonderful quiet place with good food and lovely music every day, Bocelli on the Beach, who could ask for anything more.
Sunshine Shack on Rendezvous Bay has a great beach and terrific food and service.
If you go on a Sunday, there is a myriad of options with great food and music.
If you take a Cat trip, you will see great beaches and have terrific food.
If you go on a day trip, I suggest ferry to AXA, cab to Shoal Bay East to Elodias - tell the driver you want to go to Elodias, set up there, 10.00 per person for chair and umbrella, then do a rum punch beach crawl and decide on your lunch place, there are many.
Have a great trip.
Ellen