Carol, We have stayed at SBR back when it was the Pelican. In comparing to OBBR, it is, of course, much larger. We enjoyed having almost our own pool right outside our door. But they don't have a readily available beach. One bedroom units at OBBR are much larger than our one bdrm at SBR. Of course closeness of SBR to some of our favorite restaurants was a plus for them.
They each have their advantages. Not sorry I bought at OBBR, but also glad I can exchange for other parts of the island.