A water taxi to White BAY would be very pricey - they would need to charter it for the day unless they join a day trip there....and if they are bringing coolers they can stock a few beers in, the taxi via AC is a much better idea - Smugglers is amazing. The PKs at Soggy are not what they used to be before White Bay turned into another frat party. Overpriced and overcrowded.

For a much more unique experience, go the taxi route.