Congratulations on dropping the Anegada portion as you were being way to ambitious in your plans. That can be the next trip's focus.

Generally I would hit Normans and then head up the channel to Baths as coming back with wind is a much quicker trip.

Figure out your INTENTIONS
1) how much time you want to be SAILING and how much time on land ...
2) Seems your group wants "party" experience?
3) do you want to get going before the party people get moving the next morning.
4 ) You will have captain so you don't need all hands on deck to sail.


Once you meet with your captain , discuss your "must do", which seems to be FMP at Bomba's. He will suggest an itinerary that fits 1,2 &3...

Adjust as needed... My last trip, I had planned to visit Soggy Dollar Bar and then sail a good bit that day. My group was having so much fun/relaxing on beach, we ate lunch and finally left SDB about 2pm... Sailed a short ways and anchored for the night.... Be FLEXIBLE

I haven't met any experienced captains who cannot adjust the float plan to the groups real desires and realities, resulting in a great trip (Otherwise, they become an ex-captain)