If you were planning a trip for you 35th anniversary which island would you recommend?

We honeymooned on Paradise Island but have since preferred the quieter life -- Jost Van Dyke, Tortola, east End of St. John. Not sure what is in good shape after this past year's hurricane season. Trying to plan a trip for sometime between the month of May, 2018 through September, 2018. I would really appreciate any input. We enjoy staying on the beach or within walking distance.