We've done it both ways over the years, and we're still trying to decide whether to have it delivered or head over there ourselves. We're staying the night before our charter at the Mariner Inn so we'll have time for a provisioning run if we don't wind up ordering. Sometimes it's nice to see the stuff and get fun last-minute ideas, but delivery sure is nice too!

As for liquor, we've always used Caribbean Cellars. They always had the best selection of beer, wine, and liquor on Tortola and at much better prices than I'd found anywhere else- and they deliver. I had heard they were back up and running, but my emails to them are bouncing so I need to give them a call. Anyone here dealt with Caribbean Cellars recently?