Trying to decide between two different boats in the Grenadines:

TMM's 2003 Jeanneau 43Ds - Havikah III, or Barefoot's Wind Dancer, a 2007 Catalina 400

It's only the two of us, yet the Jenneau is $700 cheaper for a two week charter. I have sailed on Elli Rose a 43DS Jeanneau in the BVI's, with 6 aboard, and think it is a lot more boat than I will need, but would like to hear from anyone who has sailed Wind Dancer, or a Catalina 400.