I am looking to stay at a clothing optional hotel with my wife in/near Orient Village. My understanding is the only 2 options that are up & operational are Adam et Eve (AE) and Club Fantastico (CF). I'm struggling as to which one to book.

I was hoping to find someone that has stayed at both places who is in a position to point out any major differences that could make this decision easier.

From the limited research that I did below are my perceptions:

AE is in more of a jungle/secluded setting whereas CF has a view of the ocean.
CF seems as to have more of a social atmosphere and guests seem to spend more time at the hotel.
AE has spa services and a more upscale dining options available.
CF has a better location that its walk able to the beach & village.
AE is a less expensive, but CF comes with drinks.
Rooms both seem to be nice so its hard to handicap.

At this point I'm looking for any information which could move the pendulum. Otherwise, I guess I'll flip a coin and will just stay at one of them now and the other on our next trip.

Thanks.