I really appreciate the info about resorts other than Club O and Fantastico; didn't know they existed and will probably try them out. The big drawback for us is that they are so small; they may be a wonderful experience but it will be totally different from Club O, where we have been going for at least 15 years. I'm sure you all know by now, but it is definite that Club O will remain closed, unless a totally new management company decides to take it on (this is from a direct letter to those still holding reservations from 2017).

If anyone has any suggestions about a Club O-type experience anywhere in the world, I would be so grateful to hear about it! I fear its type of magic is gone forever.