I agree, no bad choices that I am aware of. Blue Water Divers is a very good operation, and if Abi is willing to complete your certification, she will wear you out, but you will know you have been thoroughly trained. Sail Caribbean Divers actually has a dive shop on Cooper Island, and they are certainly a well established operation. Of course Casey and Jeff at Dive BVI are also up to the task and operate in the area. Our crew aboard 'AS YOU WISH', a Voyage 48, will be diving during December 8th - 17th. If you see us, give us a shout.