Lots of great advice. Not exactly sure what our group will want to do. I was just basing my ideas on previous trips we have had on different islands. We are always open to try something different. My biggest worry is to just be herded in like cattle and and head to a destination where you spend more time watching out for others then you do enjoying the experience.

It looks like that Oceans Frontiers might be a good option (group size around 12). Early morning definitely does not bother me. I am very early riser, but the others in my group.........well you just never know what time that they might get up. LOL.

I actually like the Mainstay option too. We are going to be renting a cat in the BVI's in 2020 for 10 days so it might be fun to try that option out too. Anyways thanks again for the advice.