After many weeks of searching various websites, perusing this forum, and asking way too many questions, I just booked this place for 5 nights in Orient Village.

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/2925277?guests=1&adults=1

A little more than I wanted to spend, but it felt like a good match for us. We will miss staying with our friends at Club Fantastico, but our budget just couldn't make it work. We are staying at Simpson Bay Resort our first 4 nights and then move to Cote Chic for 5 nights.....super stoked!!! I gave La Playa a hard look, but just didn't want to take the chance of them not making their May opening....maybe next visit.

Thanks to all for sharing info throughout my search. I will return the favor by sharing a trip report of our visit.