Thank you all so much, incredibly helpful!! I think i settled on a small Airbnb near Friars Bay, La vie est belle? Anyone ever been? Seems very basic but all we need is a bed, bathroom and kitchen really! Will definitely check out everything you listed, definitely end up at Club O Beach a couple of mornings. Thank you again!

Here is where I was thinking of staying

https://lavieestbelle-sxm.com/en/