We felt that their pizza was the best we had ever had on the island. I hope that they kept the same waitstaff as they were very personable. After our 2nd meal there, as we were leaving the waiter came hurrying after us. We thought that there was a dispute at first, but he just wanted to thank us for returning, shook my hand & gave Cleta a little hug. We too got the rum shots and loved Bread n Butter.