I don’t have an answer to that question and I’m thinking if push came to shove and you were to access the beach away from the actual Beach Club itself there wouldn’t be too much the club could do about it although they might try. I would think they should have the right to close off their property - ie their nicely done parking area, restrooms and the bar and restaurant itself, since supposedly all SXM beaches are assured to have public access but that should NOT include the beachclub itself. But to me - without the ambiance of the club - the service, the chairs, the food and all the facilities they do offer - it would be a wasted day and ride from where we stay.