I would not recommend anchoring in Deadman’s Bay on Peter Island, as you questioned on Day 1. The holding there isn’t known to be good, and i can say from experience it isn’t fun waking up to your anchor dragging at 3am. Many others on this board have echoed similar sentiments regarding anchoring there in the past. Why not consider Great Harbour right around the corner, or just head to Norman?

Day 5 you ask about dinner at Scrub or Marina Cay. There is no longer a restaurant on Marina Cay, as they closed and moved a couple months ago. I haven’t heard word of anything else opening on the island yet, though others may have some knowledge of current status.