So many to choose from! From where you are staying the following restaurants are all within walking distance: JAX Steakhouse (which is right within your resort), Le Moulin Fou (a french restaurant on the dutch side ... go figure), La Rosa Italian (right across the street), 3 Amigos (Mexican ... I believe they are still open), and the Sunset Beach Bar & Restaurant (which requires a walk down past Maho Beach). But, if you have a rental car there's a number of great choices in the Simpson Bay area and although I have not dined at all of them, they come highly recommended. These include The Palms (as noted in the posts above), Avantika, Topper's, The Greenhouse, Skip Jack's, and even the Buccaneer Beach Bar right on Kim Sha Beach. I'd suggest going to Trip Advisor and searching for the Top 10 restaurants in both the Maho area and the Simpson Bay area. Then, you can read the various reviews that have been posted to see what fits your needs.