Since I started this, I thought that I should report back. Just back from our trip. Where we snorkeled, in order that we snorkeled with relative ranking from the crew:
The Caves #6
The Rhône #7 - I stayed aboard as those mornings are close and the winds were flukey shifting from light Nw to N
Great Dogs South #3 wind and swell was up so Chimney was taken out of the equation as was Mountain Point
Big Bamboo #4a
Anegada reef with Sherry and Team Work Charters #1
Monkey Point #5
The Indians #2
Peter Island just northwest of the restaurant #4b

The quality/ranking seems to be significantly impacted by the overall time of day and cloud cover. For instance, Big Bamboo was basically cloudy and raining while the Indians was at 2 pm with a cloudless sky. We passed on Flash of Beauty because of the weather and opted to hang out with Annie at Cow Wreck instead.

Great Dog and Peter Island were huge surprises for us. Monkey Point was a bit of a disappointment maybe because it followed Anegada. The Indians looked significantly improved from 1 year ago and the conditions could not have been better.