Pat pretty much nailed it in his post. We have been to SXM many times in the last 20 years, taken multiple day trips to AXA in the past. This last May we stayed on AXA for 7 days and SXM for 3 days. Both islands have a bunch to offer.

I will definitely return to SXM in the coming years, but I really look forward to returning to AXA (sooner than later). The slow pace, beautiful beaches, fine dining options, and live music draws me to AXA.

However like Pat, but on a different island, my Caribbean heart resides. That island would be STJ (St John), but AXA is a very special place.