We enjoyed Greece, was very different. Less time in the water. Much less privacy moored stern-to-quay, but nice to be able to stroll off the boat. Inexpensive and delicious food, etc. We did it in a flotilla and were glad we did, as the docking in some of the busier harbors would have been hard to manage on our own.

We really liked Abacos (pre hurricane of course), possibly closest to BVI experience for us. Maybe the place we would have most liked to return to.

SVG was certainly enjoyable, but not up to the BVI experience. SXM even less so.

Australia ( Whitsundays ) was awesome, we are booked to return next fall. We'll see.

Thailand was certainly interesting, but had a lot of downsides and we don't feel the need to return.

Sea of Cortez also a very nice cruise.