Thanks for the excellent summary! I agree with the other comments that problems you encountered justify a partial refund rather than a future charter credit. Our group is planning to include St Croix as well (2/26 - 3/8) but hopefully without the seasickness. Can you share what the wind velocity and sea state was for your passage? We are planning to give everyone at least a day or two of shorter sails before sailing to St Croix and only if the conditions are favorable.