In no particular order of preference
Our Maho favorites include:
LeMoulin Fou
LaRosa, Too
Sublime
Cupecoy:
The Spaghetti House - not fancy but oh so good and very inexpensive by island standards
BarCode
Fat Tony’s for pizza or the Tuesday night steak special - strictly bar atmosphere
The Bodega
Simpson Bay general area:
The Palapa Grill
Mary’s Boon
And those are just for starters.