The suggestion of calling ahead is one to take!!! We are sometimes a party of 10-12 and we've had problems in the past. My number one vote for breakfast is the Yacht club!! Again word of good advise, stop by the day before or call. IMHO, Stopping by makes the difference. Splitting up in two groups, not a good idea. You are still 12 people all at once. As Carol said, it can over whelm the staff. And of course the best Bloody Mary on the island! Get the shrimp!!