Husker and GeorgeC1 - I like both those choices. Kids will have minimal bags so dropping them at Village Cay would work for the first 2 leaving. The second 2 leaving depart on the day we return the boat to TMM. Might try the same thing. (we're staying another 3 nights at Scrub so we have time to fill with gas & get the boat back to TMM).

How far in advance would you recommend buying ferry tickets? A few days? A week?