Eustatia Sound if it's not redlined. Best in settled conditions, and check the swell forecast. Great snorkeling on the reef, quiet, beaches on Prickly pear to explore.

Muskmelon Bay: I love this as a lunch stop on the way back from Anegada vs. the more crowded Monkey Point. I've actually heard there are mooring balls here now (maybe was a vessel quarantine spot). There's a small patch of sand that can fit 1-2 boats if it's anchoring only, pretty close to the rocky shore. Great snorkeling and it's fun to watch the birds fish. Backwinding can be an issue here.

I used to put Benures Bay on this list, but I think there are mooring balls now. Still much quieter relative to the Bight. Lots of sea life and you can hike all the way to Pirate's Bight if you're up for it for a cocktail. Great views. Sunsets here over the Indians and St. John are epic.