For me, not having to get into a van to go to the rental place is why I really like Kenny's. And now, with Covid, not having to get into a van with other people really seals the deal.
The customer service from Lesley and his wife have always been top notch.

Now, one of the first times we were in SXM, we made the mistake of renting from Paradise Car Rental. NEVER again. WE had an incident and the bumper of the car had a scratch of about 5 inches across the top of it. (Not such) Paradise told us they would have to replace the entire bumper of the car and wanted to charge us 4k to fix the problem. WE finally had to resort to going through our credit card company. Based on other cars in the lot, there was no way they were going to replace the bumper!

So, if you find a company you can trust, go with them. We will go with Kenny's!