Linda--Agreed, I'd park as close as possible to one of the entrances out to Maho restaurants. I personally would feel OK there until 10:30-11:00 at night, but not really after that, unless I was with someone else. Not sure what time they close at Hole in the Wall. ANY time I am out after night on the street, I make sure that my purse (if I am even carrying one) is held up close to my body.