If you have once stayed at Divi and survived the torcherous sales pitch you should try another location. LaVista is very nice but located up a hill. Restaurants near but you'll have to walk. If you rent a car you can consider staying anywhere.

Horney Toad is in the Simpson Bay area right on the beach with a couple of eating places nearby such as Mary Boon and Karakters Beach bar. If you don't mind walking it's a short way to the main area of Simpson Bay with many many good places to eat. Look through some of the back posts here for more info on dining,

The Toad has kitchens so you could shop and cook some meals to eat on your deck overlooking the ocean then walk out your unit for a swim. or contact Jeannie at Shop N Drop. You fill out a form choosing foods and she delivers to your place ready upon your arrival. See the TTOL Sonsors listed here on the site at the top of the page to contact her.