I agree that I have never personally heard of any problems during the day but I will be surprised if someone doesn't correct me. I should not really comment on the Dutch side as I don't stay there often but my sense is that it generally safer largely because it is more "urban" especially in the areas around the airport. The French side is much more "rural" and generally more "spooky" at night. I don't personally agree that Grand Case is safe. If it was the restaurant owners would not have to band together and hire private security...just saying. We find Orient Village is a nice compromise on the French side with many options in a compact, well lighted area. My sense is that Oyster pond is somewhat similar. Same for Marigot marina Just MHOs.