Years ago Pinel was just a little place for local families to pack a picnic lunch & have a peaceful day. Now it's a zoo in my mind with restaurants & noisy water toys. When we discovered Prickly Pear there were just a couple small private sailboats & our cat. No food places at all. I don't know if there's a less visited island - how is Tintamarre? Have you looked into that? Maybe someone can give you some information on a less busy place. There's Sandy Island but I'm willing to bet there's a restaurant on that by now!