Two years ago as 2 couples in our 30's we did Aquamania to Anguilla with a snorkel stop at Prickly Pear along the way. We had a blast. Half the fun of those trips is the drinking and fun on the boat to and from. This year we plan to ferry and rent a car to explore.

It really comes down to what do you want to do? From what I understand you can still have a great time beach hopping on your own etc and checking out the local beach bars.