Totally agree regarding Tortola. You could not pay me enough to get on a scooter there. Interested to hear about Walker's story. I mean, you definitely need to keep an eye out for traffic both in front and behind so you don't get run over by a cab driver or a tourist in a safari bus staring at the flamingos instead of watching where they are going, but Anegada is flat, the roads are for the most part plenty wide and there just aren't that many cars on the road. I've really never thought it was that bad at all. And I'm the kind of guy that HATES taking dumb risks, especially when on vacation.

Anyway, if you're not up for the scooter thing, or even think you're not, probably a good idea not to tempt fate, just rent a car. No doubt there!