Of those on your list, we have only stayed at Club O and Beachside Villas. Both very nice, both obviously different from each other. We enjoy Club O for the restful, easy time -- no rushing (or traffic) to and from the beach, being able to go back to your studio for a nap 'whenever', not having to worry about what to wear on most days. <img src="http://www.traveltalkonline.com/forums/images/graemlins/jester.gif" alt="" /> One caveat is the lack of nightlife (if that matters to you) unless you drive.
BSV is also very nice, right on the beach, steps down to the sand. The only caveat we have there (and this doesn't bother some folks and might not bother you) is that there is only A/C in the bedrooms, not in the living area. During high season it's not so bad, but during warmer periods, it can be a little uncomfortable. Also be aware that there are only TV's in the living room, not in the bedrooms -- which is fine by me. Your mileage may vary.
.
