we have 9 of us ages 13-70 so it is hard to please everyone - we stay in maho but rent a van- - we mostly eat American and Italian - here is what we will probably do:
1) Cheri's - we go every year for the atmosphere, have been going since my son was 5
2) Il Nettuno - one of our favorite spots (taking the family there this year, usually we go with just the 2 of us)
3) Bajatzu Bar & Grille - never did but may do just wife and I
4) Cugini Trattoria - never went - looking for feedback
5) Aglio Olio - had a great time there last year

any other suggestions?