Were I a timeshare owner there I would not be happy with that offer at all. Our experience so far regarding selling timeshare weeks has been positive. Although we lost money on all of them [we had bought them from the resorts, which I would never advise anyone to do] we did sell them directly and the transfer process was smooth. I would not "give it back." I'd rent it out until you sell it. Lately more for-sale units are moving but it's still a buyer's market, even for Simpson Bay which is almost completely renovated. [N. B., my comments are based on what we're seeing on the sales/rentals page of my site... whether that is statistically significant I have no idea. Rentals are moving faster now than in the prior 10 years. I'm wondering whether others are seeing that as well? If so it is a huge positive indicator for future SXM tourism, for this coming winter anyway.]