Hi everyone. I posted this on USVI and Southern C as well in hope to get as many opinions as possible! We LOVE St John but are considering an alternative to see a new island. Love the calm waters, easy in snorkeling, nice people, et al. We rent villas so we don't need hotel or resort living but also don't want an island where the roads are so bad driving is like taking your life in your hands (heard that about BVI's). Looking for white sand beaches, villa/home rental options and calm, clear waters for swimming and snorkeling. Wondering about Grenada, Grenadines, Virgin Gorda.. heard Antigua had limited snorkeling or was it easy in swimming? Anyway, I would really appreciate the help as the internet is making my head swirl! Thanks!