It's funny - we gave up on the Hideaway about 5 years ago for all the usual reasons - service, quality, experience. And since it is right across from our timeshare it was a loss! And then in March we tried it again when my brother wanted to go - and I was happy again! 4 out of the 5 meals were excellent & the one that wasn't was good, just not rave worthy. I only remember my dinner which was the seafood in puff pastry. So we'll go back next year. We also had an uncharacteristically awful meal at Pineapple Pete's, but we'll go back cuz we had too many good times not to. Plus Pete made good on our meals. I know when I cook not everything I make comes out the way I want it, but then I'm not a chef or paying a lot of money for the meal