We have flown on air sunshine several times without any problems. Does that mean it's safe?

It's a vintage twin engine Cessna just like cape air.

Personally, I think that the worst part of the trip to VG is the landing strip and approach.

Warren S/V Scuba Doo
Lagoon 50 (winner of best crewed yacht under 55 feet at the St. Thomas crewed yacht boat show).

https://www.cyabrochure.com/ebn/2307/pdyrX/6642/4///