I agree with all of the suggestions you've gotten thus far - maybe you should've asked where NOT to go
It depends on your definition of a good time, really. And the day of the week. Buccaneer is definitely laid back with great food and drinks. Topper's has good food (everything from osso bucco - Friday's only - to wings) and live music every night. Some nights are karaoke and some singers are better than others. Topper's by the Sea has a Thursday night show that is fun - if you're there when Ricky Fox is doing his show, it's worth seeing.
The Harbor has live music every night, as well. Ranging from salsa music to classic rock. Good food and drinks and probably the nicest restrooms in the area
La Bamba, sadly, closed on November 21.
Red Piano is lots of fun - no food, though.
Bon Appetite has good food and most nights has live, low key, musicians playing on the patio.
The great thing about your location is that you can try one recommendation found here and, if you don't like it, you can walk to another location within minutes.
Enjoy!
